Payton Tolle

Boston Red Sox · baseball

Payton Tolle Red Rookie card is on the 2026 Bowman Red RC Baseball checklist. Only a Rookie of the Year winner can redeem.

Last sold $3.65Sep 15, 2026

BoxNo box
RoleSitting
BookBuilding
PrintIn line

4.2 IP, ER, 4 K, BB @ NYY · 0/14d · 16 prints · last $3.65 vs $2.99 FMV

Current eBay listings

No games in this window.

Official Hobby: hobby slang · redemptions

Season

2026 Playoffs season

ERA: 1.93
IP: 4.2
SO: 4
WHIP: 1.29
GS: 1

Redemption status

Active

Payton Tolle is active in the 2026 Bowman Red RC Baseball checklist. Still eligible for this redemption program. Connelly Early is on the same Boston Red Sox checklist.

Games

Last game

BOS 0–9 NYYL

@ NYY · Tue, Sep 29

Highlights

4.2 IP, ER, 4 K, BB

Tue, Sep 29

Upcoming

Off

No next game on the slate

Red Rookie

Base #26

FMV

$2.99

90d · vs last refresh

Window

Last sold

$3.65

Sep 15

PriceNeutral

VolumeBuilding16 prints · 9/14d

Sep 3Sep 6Sep 9Sep 12Sep 16

Volume

Official Hobby: comps and raw · how to price

Market lean

Payton Tolle holds a neutral lean as buyers weigh a breakout 26-start campaign and an immaculate inning against modest raw single price points.

Overall market

Holding down a major league rotation spot for the Boston Red Sox, left-hander Payton Tolle put together 26 starts spanning 148.2 innings in 2026, dropping his ERA to 3.03 with a 1.10 WHIP and 171 strikeouts. That workload marks a massive step forward from his 16.1 innings in 2025, giving collectors a real foundation of production to evaluate on the mound.

Raw singles for the Boston starter trade as cheap singles on active flow, with his 2026 Bowman Baseball Red RC checking in consistently on sold listings. BIN buyers can easily source these ungraded cards while tracking how the market reacts to a starter who racks up strikeouts.

Highlight reels from the season caught attention when the lefty opened a start against the Kansas City Royals with an immaculate inning, showcasing his swing-and-miss stuff. His late-season outings, such as a 4.2-inning turn against the Yankees yielding one earned run, give collectors concrete data points to hold.

With rookie eligibility still intact, every quality turn through the rotation keeps interest steady among buyers looking for affordable pitching upside.

Hobby takeaway

Hold your raw Red RC from the 2025-26 Bowman Chrome checklist while this rotation arm secures more starter volume.

Performance notes

Season lines, role, and the box score levers that move the Red RC chase and checklist.

Locking down a permanent rotation spot for the Boston Red Sox, pitcher Payton Tolle handled 26 starts across 148.2 innings of work with a 3.03 ERA and 171 strikeouts. The left-hander added a notable highlight to his resume recently by opening a start against Kansas City with an immaculate inning. In his final outing against the Yankees, he worked 4.2 frames, allowing one earned run with four strikeouts and a walk.

About

Payton Tolle is a physically imposing, towering 6'6" left handed starting pitcher hailing from Yukon, Oklahoma. After launching his collegiate career as a dominant two way force at Wichita State, Tolle transferred to the Big 12 where he put together a historic, award-winning season leading the TCU Horned Frogs as the nation's premier strikeout artist. Selected by the Boston Red Sox, Tolle focused entirely on his arm and rapidly crushed minor league hitting before earning an early promotion to Fenway Park. Weaponizing a deceptive, high-extension mid-90s fastball and a sharp slider from a difficult, low-slot release angle, Tolle generates massive swing-and-miss numbers.

Key notes: 2024: Big 12 Pitcher of the Year & Consensus First-Team All-American; 2024: Selected 2nd Round (No. 50 Overall) by the Boston Red Sox in the 2024; MLB Draft; 2025: Promoted to the Major Leagues, logging his official MLB debut; 2026: Maintained Red Rookie Redemption eligibility while solidifying a permanent frontline starting role.